• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Screwtape Letter 12 Analysis Essay

Summary: Letter 10

Screwtape is glad to hear that the Patient has made new friends, a couple that is superficially intelligent, fashionably communist, and skeptical of everything in the world. Wormwood should make the Patient his new friends in order to please them. People become what they pretend to be. The Patient may not realize for a long time that his new friendship is a worldly temptation, but he will realize eventually. If the Patient is a fool, Wormwood can see to it that he only recognizes his friends’ failings when he is not with them. Wormwood should try to divide the Patient in half, make him feel superior to other churchgoers because he has such worldly friends and superior to his friends because they can’t understand his spiritual life. This will make the Patient vain and self-satisfied. In the meantime, he should be sure the Patient spends more than he can afford and neglects his work and mother.

Summary: Letter 11

The Patient’s new friends have introduced him to their whole set. Screwtape thinks it is a good sign, warns the Patient’s laughter might be dangerous. Laughter has four causes: Joy, Fun, the Joke Proper, and Flippancy. The cause of laughter when humans experience Joy, says Screwtape, is unknown, but Joy doesn’t win souls to Hell. Fun, which arises from the “play instinct” is like Joy. It’s not very useful, but it distracts people from doing other things the Enemy has in mind for them. Jokes are much more promising as a way to win souls. Humans, especially the British, writes Screwtape, can excuse any vice by making a joke of it. Cowardice is acceptable so long as one brags about it in a comical manner. Flippancy, however, is the best of all. Flippant people don’t actually laugh, they just assume everything is laughable. They take nothing seriously, not even virtue. This isolates them from the Enemy, and, contrary to what they believe, it does not make them more intelligent.

Summary: Letter 12

Screwtape praises Wormwood for making good progress Wormwood must make sure the Patient doesn’t realize that he has begun to move away from the Enemy. Screwtape is almost glad that the Patient still goes to church. This way, the Patient will think he is a Christian even if he doesn’t act like one. Wormwood should keep the Patient from recognizing his vague feeling that he “hasn’t been doing very well lately” as sin. He should make the Patient feel bad, but only vaguely. This will make him reluctant to think of the Enemy and prevent him from repenting or changing his ways. Soon the Patient will want to be distracted from prayer because praying, by making him conscious of his guilt, will make him feel bad. Then, as time goes on, the Patient will allow himself to be distracted by anything or nothing. For Wormwood’s purposes, . will spend his time neither having fun nor living rightly.

Analysis

events of the Patient’s life are painted with a very broad brush. The reader learns the Patient has made friends, but not how he made them, that the Patient’s friends are worldly and skeptical people, but not what made them that way, that the Patient has a job, but not what his job is. Screwtape considers these details irrelevant to the Patient’s temptation. Screwtape, feigning ignorance about the Patient, often even offers advice about several different character types. He gives Wormwood a range of possible actions depending on what kind of man he thinks the Patient is. The reader is encouraged, then, to think of as “the Patient,” rather than to think of the Patient as a distinct and specific character. The figures in the Patient’s life become examples of broader life categories. His new friends, for example, represent the idea of shallow friendship, rather than specific characters the reader might like or dislike based on their concrete attributes.

World War II encouraged individuals to evaluate their conduct through the lens of crisis. Was it appropriate, for example, given the mass-scale destruction and loss of life unfolding throughout Europe, for people to have fun and laugh? Screwtape’s warning is that there are many forms of laughter , like the laughter caused by joy when old friends see each other after a long time separated, are purely good and therefore of no use in leading humans to Hell. aughter, like sex, can be pursued as an end in itself. People can be tricked into chasing its diminishing pleasures instead of growing closer to God.

The twelfth letter is the only one in which Screwtape praises Wormwood for his work on the Patient. Usually, Screwtape criticizes Wormwood, for having a poor temptation strategy in general, and for being too excited about World War II in particular. Wormwood’s excitement about the war, Screwtape says, distracts him from using it as a means to win the Patient’s soul. For the moment, however, things seem to be looking good for Hell. The Patient has come under the bad influence of skeptical friends. He is beginning to become a hypocrite. Because people are reluctant to acknowledge their own hypocrisy, it alienates them from themselves. That’s why hypocrisy is, according to Screwtape, Hell’s greatest weapons. Wormwood’s objective is two-fold. First, he should tempt the Patient away from God and into eternal damnation, and, second, he should make the Patient lead a miserable and meaningless life without ever really understanding the cause of his unhappiness.

The Screwtape Letters is a Christian apologetic novel by C. S. Lewis. It is written in a satirical, epistolary style and while it is fictional in format, the plot and characters are used to address Christian theological issues, primarily those to do with temptation and resistance to it.

First published in February 1942, the story takes the form of a series of letters from a senior DemonScrewtape to his nephew Wormwood, a Junior Tempter. The uncle's mentorship pertains to the nephew's responsibility in securing the damnation of a British man known only as "the Patient".

Summary[edit]

In The Screwtape Letters, C. S. Lewis provides a series of lessons in the importance of taking a deliberate role in Christian faith by portraying a typical human life, with all its temptations and failings, seen from devils' viewpoints. Screwtape holds an administrative post in the bureaucracy ("Lowerarchy") of Hell, and acts as a mentor to his nephew Wormwood, an inexperienced (and incompetent) tempter.

In the thirty-one letters which constitute the book, Screwtape gives Wormwood detailed advice on various methods of undermining faith and of promoting sin in "the Patient", interspersed with observations on human nature and on Christian doctrine. In Screwtape's advice, selfish gain and power are seen as the only good, and neither demon can comprehend God's love for man or acknowledge human virtue.

Versions of the letters were originally published weekly in the Anglican periodical The Guardian, in wartime between May and November 1941,[3] and the standard edition contains an introduction explaining how the author chose to write his story.

Lewis wrote the sequel "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" in 1959 – a critique of certain trends in British public education. (Although Britain calls its major private schools "public schools", Lewis is referring to state schools when he criticizes "public education".) Omnibus editions with a new preface by Lewis were published by Bles in 1961 and by Macmillan in 1962.

The Screwtape Letters became one of Lewis' most popular works, although he claimed that it was "not fun" to write and "resolved never to write another 'Letter'".[4]

Both The Screwtape Letters and "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" have been released on both audio cassette and CD, with narrations by John Cleese, Joss Ackland and Ralph Cosham.

Plot overview[edit]

The Screwtape Letters comprises 31 letters written by a senior demon named Screwtape to his nephew, Wormwood (named after a star in Revelation), a younger and less experienced demon, charged with guiding a man (called "the patient") toward "Our Father Below" (Devil / Satan) from "the Enemy" (God).

After the second letter, the Patient converts to Christianity, and Wormwood is chastised for allowing this. A striking contrast is formed between Wormwood and Screwtape during the rest of the book, wherein Wormwood is depicted through Screwtape's letters as anxious to tempt his patient into extravagantly wicked and deplorable sins, often recklessly, while Screwtape takes a more subtle stance, as in Letter XII wherein he remarks: "... the safest road to hell is the gradual one - the gentle slope, soft underfoot, without sudden turnings, without milestones, without signposts".

In Letter VIII, Screwtape explains to his protégé the different purposes that God and the devils have for the human race: "We want cattle who can finally become food; He wants servants who can finally become sons". With this end in mind, Screwtape urges Wormwood in Letter VI to promote passivity and irresponsibility in the Patient: "(God) wants men to be concerned with what they do; our business is to keep them thinking about what will happen to them".

With his own views on theology, Lewis goes on to describe and discuss sex, love, pride, gluttony, and war in successive letters. Lewis, an Oxford and Cambridgescholar himself, suggests in his work that even intellectuals are not impervious to the influence of such demons, especially during complacent acceptance of the "Historical Point of View" (Letter XXVII).

In Letter XXII, after several attempts to find a licentious woman for the Patient "to promote a useful marriage", and after Screwtape's receiving a painful punishment for having divulged to Wormwood God's genuine love for humanity (which Wormwood informed the Infernal authorities about), Screwtape notes that the Patient has fallen in love with a Christian girl and through her and her family a very Christian way of life. Toward the end of this letter, in his anger Screwtape becomes a large centipede, mimicking a similar transformation in Book X of Paradise Lost, wherein the demons are changed into snakes. Later in the correspondence, it is revealed that the young man may be placed in harm's way by his possibly Civil defense duties (it is stated in an earlier letter that he is eligible for military service, but it is never actually confirmed that he was indeed called up). While Wormwood is delighted at this and by the war in general, Screwtape admonishes Wormwood to keep the Patient safe, in hopes that they can compromise his faith over a long lifetime.

In the last letter, the Patient has been killed during a World War IIair raid and has gone to Heaven, and for his ultimate failure Wormwood is doomed to suffer the consumption of his spiritual essence by the other demons, especially by Screwtape himself. Screwtape responds to Wormwood's final letter that he may expect as little assistance as Screwtape would expect from Wormwood were their situations reversed ("My love for you and your love for me are as alike as two peas ... The only difference is that I am the stronger."), mimicking the situation where Wormwood himself informed on his uncle to the Infernal Police for Infernal Heresy (making a religiously positive remark that would offend Satan).

Literary sequels[edit]

"Screwtape Proposes a Toast"[edit]

The short sequel "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" (1959), first published as an article in the Saturday Evening Post, is an addendum to The Screwtape Letters; the two works are often published together as one book.[5] "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" takes the form of an after-dinner speech given by Screwtape at the Tempters' Training College for young demons. In stage adaptations it is sometimes added as a prelude, making the work a prequel. "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" is Lewis' criticism of leveling and featherbedding trends in public education; more specifically, as he reveals in the foreword to the American edition, public education in America (though in the text, it is English education that is held up as the purportedly awful example).[citation needed]

The Cold War opposition between the West and the Communist World is explicitly discussed as a backdrop to the educational issues. Screwtape and other demons are portrayed as consciously using the subversion of education and intellectual thought in the West to bring about its overthrow by the communist enemy from without and within. In this sense "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" is more strongly political than The Screwtape Letters, wherein no strong stand is made on political issues of the day, such as World War II.[6]

Other literary sequels[edit]

Though C. S. Lewis had resolved not to write another letter, and only revisited the character of Screwtape once, in Screwtape Proposes a Toast, the format, referred to by Lewis himself as a kind of "demonic ventriloquism", has inspired other authors to prepare sequels or similar works, such as:

  • Alcorn, Randy (2001). Lord Foulgrin's Letters. ISBN 978-1-57673-861-0. 
  • Deace, Steve. (2016). A Nefarious Plot. ISBN 978-1-61868-823-1. [7]
  • Forest, Jim (2004). The Wormwood File: E-mail From Hell. ISBN 978-1-57075-554-5.  Another Wormwood series of instructions.
  • Kreeft, Peter (1998). The Snakebite Letters: Devilishly Devious Secrets for Subverting Society as Taught in Tempter's Training School. ISBN 978-0-89870-721-2. 
  • Laymon, Barbara (2004). The Devil's Inbox. ISBN 978-0-8066-4945-0. 
  • Martin, Walter R. (1975). Screwtape Writes Again. ISBN 978-0-88449-033-3. [8]
  • Miles, Bryan (2003). The Wormwood Letters. ISBN 978-0-595-28392-7.  Wormwood, who has somehow survived, now finds himself in a new era writing to his own nephew, Soulsniper.
  • Peschke, Jim (2010). The Michael Letters: Heaven's answer to Screwtape. ISBN 978-1-4536-6027-0.  The Archangel Michael provides advice to Jacob, a guardian angel.
  • Platt, Richard (2012). As One Devil to Another: A Fiendish Correspondence in the Tradition of C. S. Lewis' The Screwtape Letters. ISBN 978-1-4143-7166-5. 
  • Williams, Arthur H., Jr. (2006). The Screwtape Email. ISBN 978-1-4120-0067-3. 
  • Longenecker, Dwight (2009). The Gargoyle Code: Lenten Letters between a Master Tempter and his diabolical Trainee. ISBN 978-0615673851. Master Tempter Slubgrip advises Dogwart how to corrupt a young Catholic, while struggling to control his own ‘patient.’

Adaptations[edit]

Audio drama[edit]

Focus on the Family Radio Theatre, a project of Focus on the Family, was granted the rights to dramatize The Screwtape Letters as a feature length audio drama. Production began in 2008, and the product was released in the fall of 2009.[9]Andy Serkis, known for playing Gollum in The Lord of the Rings film trilogy, provides the voice for Screwtape, with Bertie Carvel as Wormwood, Philip Bird as The Patient (identified in this production as "John Hamilton"), Laura Michael Kelly as The Girl (identified in this production as "Dorothy"), Roger Hammond as Toadpipe, Christina Greatrex as Slumtrimpet, Janet Henfrey as Glubose, Philip Sherlock as the Messenger, Susie Brann as the Presenter and Geoffrey Palmer as C.S. Lewis. There is a 7-and-a-half minute video preview of the Radio Theatre production with interviews and making-of footage.[10] This production was a 2010 Audie Award finalist.

Comic book adaptation[edit]

Marvel Comics and religious book publisher Thomas Nelson produced a comic book adaptation of The Screwtape Letters in 1994.[11]

Film adaptation[edit]

The Screwtape Letters is a planned film based on the novel. 20th Century Fox bought the film rights to the book in the 1950s and partnered with Walden Media to make this film as they were doing with The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (2010). Walden originally intended to release the film in 2008.[12]Ralph Winter, the producer, credited the success of the Chronicles of Narnia film series for the greenlighting of The Screwtape Letters.[13]The Screwtape Letters is to be a live-action film.[14] Because the novel is a series of letters with limited action, critics have questioned how a film adaptation is possible.[15]

Stage adaptation[edit]

The stage play Dear Wormwood (later renamed Screwtape), written by James Forsyth, was published in 1961. The setting is changed to wartime London, where we actually see Wormwood going about the business of tempting his "patient" (in the play, given the name "Michael Green"). The ending is changed as well, with Wormwood trying to repent and beg for forgiveness, when it appears that his mission has failed. "Dear Wormwood" premiered in Luther High School North, Chicago, IL in April, 1961.

Philadelphia playwright and actor Anthony Lawton's original adaptation of The Screwtape Letters has been staged several times since 2000 by Lantern Theater Company, most recently in May/June 2014. In Lawton's adaptation, each of Screwtape's letters is punctuated by varied dances including tap, Latinballroom, jazz, martial arts, and rock – and whips and fire-eating. Screwtape performs these dances with his secretary, Toadpipe.

The Fellowship for the Performing Arts obtained from the Lewis estate the rights to adapt The Screwtape Letters for the stage. The initial production opened off-off-Broadway at Theatre 315 in New York City in January 2006. The initial three-week run was extended to eleven and finally closed because the theater was contractually obligated to another production.[16] It was co-written by Max McLean (who also starred) and Jeffrey Fiske (who also directed). A second, expanded production opened off Broadway at the Theatre at St. Clements on 18 October 2007, originally scheduled to run through 6 January 2008. The production re-opened at the Mercury Theater in Chicago in September 2008, and continued on a national tour including San Francisco, Phoenix, Louisville, Chattanooga, Fort Lauderdale, Houston and Austin, through January 2010 as well as playing at The Shakespeare Theatre in Washington, D.C. for ten weeks.[17]The Screwtape Letters played for 309 performances at New York City's Westside Theatre in 2010. The 2011 tour visited performing arts venues in cities throughout the United States including Los Angeles, Houston, Dallas, Atlanta, Seattle, Minneapolis, and Boston. The 2012–2013 tour began in Los Angeles in January 2012, with return engagements in San Francisco, San Diego, Seattle, Chicago and Atlanta as well as stops in several other cities. The Screwtape Letters has been described as "Humorous and lively ... the Devil has rarely been given his due more perceptively!" by The New York Times, "A profound experience" by Christianity Today and "Wickedly witty ... One hell of good show!" by The Wall Street Journal.[17]

The Barley Sheaf Players of Lionville, Pennsylvania performed James Forsyth's play Screwtape in September 2010. It was directed by Scott Ryan and the play ran the last 3 weekends in September.[18] The production was reviewed by Paul Recupero for Stage Magazine.[19]

In popular culture[edit]

Documentary[edit]

Affectionately Yours, Screwtape: The Devil and C.S. Lewis (January 1, 2007), directed by Tom Dallis and written by Amy Dallis, aired on the History Channel[20]

Literature[edit]

In 2010, the Marine Corps Gazette began publishing a series of articles entitled "The Attritionist Letters" styled in the manner of The Screwtape Letters. In the letters, General Screwtape chastises Captain Wormwood for his inexperience and naivete while denouncing the concepts of maneuver warfare in favor of attrition warfare.[21]

Music[edit]

Called To Arms' concept album Peril and the Patient (August 10, 2010) is based entirely on The Screwtape Letters.[22][23]

In U2's music video for the song "Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me" (1995), an animated Bono is seen walking down the street holding the book The Screwtape Letters. While on stage during the Zoo TV Tour Bono would dress as Mr. MacPhisto, his alter ego. Bono would wear a gold suit and devil horns and usually make prank calls to politicians.

The lyrics for The Receiving End of Sirens' song "Oubliette (Disappear)", from the album The Earth Sings Mi Fa Mi (2007) were inspired by a passage from The Screwtape Letters.[24]

In the Christian metal band Living Sacrifice's album Ghost Thief, there is a track titled "Screwtape". Frontman of Living Sacrifice, Bruce Fitzhugh, explained that the song is "about temptation and the proverbial 'devil on your shoulder.' It's about the thought process we go through to justify a thought or action that is not good for the soul". Fitzhugh also explains how he thought it was interesting Lewis wrote from the perspective of Screwtape and that he wrote from the same perspective in the song.[25]

The group The Oh Hellos released the album Dear Wormwood which they have described as a form of speculative fiction from the point of view of "the patient".

Speeches[edit]

U.S. PresidentRonald Reagan quoted from The Screwtape Letters in his famous 1983 speech to the National Association of Evangelicals.[26]

Reviews[edit]

"C.S. Lewis is the most popular Christian theologian being published today." - The Christian Book Club

"Lewis is the ideal persuader for the half-convinced, for the good man who would like to be a Christian but finds his intellect getting in the way." - Anthony Burgess, The New York Times Book Review

"Apparently this Oxford don and Cambridge professor is going to be around for a long time; he called himself a dinosaur but he seems to speak to people where they are." - Chad Walsh, The Washington Post Book World

"A legacy of solid, genial Christianity." - Dorothy Dohen, Commonweal

Other uses[edit]

David Foster Wallace praised the book in interviews and placed it first on his list of top ten favorite books.[27]

In an October 2013 interview in New York magazine, U.S. Supreme CourtJusticeAntonin Scalia, professed his admiration for the book. Scalia remarked, "The Screwtape Letters is a great book. It really is, just as a study of human nature." The book was discussed in the highly publicized interview during Scalia's discourse regarding the nature of his Catholic faith.[28]

Notes[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^Griffin, William (2005), C.S. Lewis: The Authentic Voice, Oxford: Lion Hudson, p. 188, ISBN 0-7459-5208-9 .
  2. ^Lewis, C. S. (2001), The Screwtape Letters, New York: HarperCollins, p. 184 
  3. ^Lewis, C. S. (2001). The Screwtape Letters, with Screwtape Proposes a Toast. HarperSanFrancisco. ISBN 0-06-065293-4. 
  4. ^Hein, David (2007). "A Note on C. S. Lewis's The Screwtape Letters". The Anglican Digest. 49 (2). pp. 55–58. 
  5. ^https://www.amazon.com/Nefarious-Plot-Steve-Deace/dp/1618688235/
  6. ^https://www.abebooks.com/products/isbn/9780884490333/198728758
  7. ^"Radio Theatre". Radio Theatre. 2013-03-23. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  8. ^"Video preview of The Screwtape Letters Audio Drama". chriskou.com. May 22, 2009. 
  9. ^Lewis, C. S. The Screwtape Letters. The Christian classic series. New York: Marvel Comics, 1994. ISBN 978-0-8407-6261-0
  10. ^Nicole Laporte (2007-01-31). "'Screwtape' attaches Walden". Variety. Retrieved 2009-07-15. 
  11. ^"Update on The Screwtape Letters Movie From Producer Ralph Winter". The Stone Table. 2007-02-17. Retrieved 2009-07-15. 
  12. ^"'Screwtape Letters' to be released on film". Catholic News Agency. Retrieved July 15, 2009. 
  13. ^"Another CS Lewis Film In The Works". Empire. January 2, 2007. Retrieved July 15, 2009. 
  14. ^"About the NYC Production of C.S. Lewis' The Screwtape Letters". Archived from the original on 2007-10-27. Retrieved 2007-10-06. 
  15. ^ ab"About The Screwtape Letters", ScrewtapeOnStage. Retrieved on 27 January 2012.
  16. ^"Barley Sheaf Players Screwtape"
  17. ^Recupero, Paul. "Turn of the SCREWTAPE", Stage Magazine Review, September 10, 2010.
  18. ^Dallis, Tom (Director) & Dallis, Amy (Writer) (January 1, 2007). "Affectionately Yours, Screwtape: The Devil and C.S. Lewis". IMDb. 
  19. ^"The Attritionist Letters (Archives)". Marine Corps Gazette. MCA Marines. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  20. ^"Called to Arms is Rad" (news). Indie Vision Music. 2010-05-21. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  21. ^"Called To Arms" (profile). Absolute Punk. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  22. ^"Disappear (Oubliette) Lyric Meaning – The Receiving End of Sirens Meanings". Song meanings. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  23. ^"Living Sacrifice's "Screwtape" song premiere". Lambgoat. Retrieved January 12, 2016. 
  24. ^"Remarks at the Annual Convention of the National Association of Evangelicals in Orlando, Florida"(PDF). The Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation and Library. March 8, 1983. Retrieved July 15, 2014. 
  25. ^"David Foster Wallace: R.I.P."News observer. September 16, 2008. Archived from the original on 2008-10-31. Retrieved 2013-04-29. 
  26. ^"In Conversation: Antonin Scalia". New York. Retrieved October 6, 2013. 

Bibliography[edit]

External links[edit]

  1. ^The Screwtape Letters title listing at the Internet Speculative Fiction Database. Select a title to see its linked publication history and general information. Select a particular edition (title) for more data at that level, such as a front cover image or linked contents.
    • ISFDB shows unillustrated covers, and credits no cover artists, for both first editions published by Geoffrey Bles, the Letters (1942) and the omnibus with "Screwtape Proposes a Toast" and a new preface by Lewis (1961).

One thought on “Screwtape Letter 12 Analysis Essay

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *